Monday, February 13, 2012

The fantasy is crumbling

Turbines are a 'public menace' and wind is the 'least efficient' renewable power, National Trust says


Wind turbines are a ‘public menace’, the chairman of the National Trust chairman has said.

Sir Simon Jenkins dismissed wind as the ‘least efficient’ renewable power.

The honest admission is surprising coming from the the head of the charity, as it champions green energy as part of its conservation work.

While the National Trust officially continues to support ‘a major increase in the UK’s renewable energy generation’, it is fighting several plans for wind farms, including one to erect a massive 417 wind turbines in the Bristol Channel.

‘We are doing masses of renewables but wind is probably the least efficient and wrecks the countryside,’ he said.

The trust is concerned about the impact of the 220m (721ft) turbines on the environment and on views of the coastline.


The trust remains committed to its target to cut energy use by 50 per cent by 2020, but Sir Simon told the Daily Telegraph this would largely be achieved through water power and biomass boilers, making the most of the acres of rivers and woodlands under its ownership.

It is also disputing the Duke of Gloucester’s plans to build four 415ft turbines on his Barnwell Manor Estate in Northamptonshire.

The revelation could be a major a blow to the Coalition government, which has recently come to blows with the Trust over plans to reform planning law.

Last week Ed Davey, who replaced Chris Huhne as Energy and Climate Change secretary, boasted that Britain had ‘a lot to be proud of’ after the world’s biggest offshore farm – consisting of 102 turbines - opened off the Cumbrian coast.

Up to 32,000 wind turbines could be built in England and Wales over the next 40 years to meet government targets.

But last month it emerged that wind farms in Scotland were paid nearly £300,000 in the first five days of this year to close down because it was too windy.

Four turbine operators shared the controversial ‘constraint payments’ because they produced more energy than the National Grid could handle.

Last year 17 wind farm operators were paid £7m to shut down on 40 occasions between January and September.




1 comment:

schmdoug said...

In what sense is he using the term "inefficient". I work at a major utility in the US. And we have to back down our coal plants and night and during low load situations to account for wind power. But I don't know if I would term this problem as "inefficient". What is more a problem is the fact that the generation from the wind farms gets curtailed due to transmission constraints. And the fact that the rest of the grid/grid generation is not built to accommodate the variability of wind generation.