Thursday, January 30, 2020

Which Bolton to believe?


'GAME OVER!' Donald Trump claims victory with video of John Bolton calling his call to Ukraine's Zelensky 'warm and cordial' as White House fights to stop him giving evidence

  • John Bolton's book The Room Where It Happened has caused shockwaves in Washington D.C. even though it is not published until March 17
  •  Donald Trump tweeted a resurfaced video of John Bolton from August 27 calling the infamous call to Vladimir Zelensky 'warm and cordial'
  • He also said that the Trump administration was interested in corruption, a key element of the president's defense against impeachment 
  • The White House has written to his attorneys to say that it contains 'top secret' classified information and cannot be published in its current form
  • Bolton is told he has to delete the  information if he wants to publish book for which he signed a reputed $2 million deal
  • White House bid to ban book was made public just as senators started asking questions in Donald Trump's impeachment trial
  • Democrats seized on move demanding to know exactly when his defense team knew about the explosive contents of the memoir By GEOFF EARLE, DEPUTY U.S. POLITICAL EDITOR FOR DAILYMAIL.COM and REUTERS and ASSOCIATED PRESS
    Donald Trump tweeted a resurfaced video of John Bolton calling the notorious call to Ukraine's Volodymr Zelensky 'warm and cordial' on Wednesday afternoon and crowed: 'GAME OVER!'
    The president's defense against impeachment has been rocked by revelations that Bolton's book will say he explicitly tied Ukraine aid to a probe into Joe and Hunter Biden.
    He seized on the interview Bolton conducted with Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty while he was still the national security advisor, in which he said that the Trump administration was concerned with corruption, and that the president's two calls with the newly-inaugurated Zelensky were 'warm and cordial.'
    'They were very warm and cordial calls. We're hoping that they will be able to meet in Warsaw and have a few minutes together because the success of Ukraine, maintaining its freedom, its system of representative government, a free market economy free of corruption and dealing with the problems of the Donbass and the Crimea are high priorities here, obviously, but are high priorities for the United States,' Bolton said in an interview broadcast on August 27.
    Fight back: How Trump leaped on  John Bolton's August 27 interview which the president's supporters see as proof Bolton should not give evidence
    Fight back: How Trump leaped on  John Bolton's August 27 interview which the president's supporters see as proof Bolton should not give evidence 
    Focus of defense - and prosecution: Trump's defense includes that he was focused on corruption in Ukraine and that was why he asked Ukraine's president Volodymr Zelensky for probes. Bolton's interview is being seen as supporting that.
    Focus of defense - and prosecution: Trump's defense includes that he was focused on corruption in Ukraine and that was why he asked Ukraine's president Volodymr Zelensky for probes. Bolton's interview is being seen as supporting that.
    Democratic case: House impeachment managers highlighted the lack of the use of the word 'corruption' in the call and the lack of apparent evidence of previous interest in the topic by the president as they pressed their case against him
    Democratic case: House impeachment managers highlighted the lack of the use of the word 'corruption' in the call and the lack of apparent evidence of previous interest in the topic by the president as they pressed their case against him
    The video had been circulated widely in conservative circles Wednesday as the maelstrom over Bolton's forthcoming book worsened.
    Trump's supporters saw it as evidence that Bolton's manuscript was not in keeping with his past statements - useful to discredit him as a witness, if he were to be called, and also as a tool to dissuade Republican senators from voting to have him give evidence.
    Its mention of corruption would appear to offer support to a key plank of Trump's defense: that he wanted to root out corruption in Ukraine and that asking for probes was a legitimate part of foreign policy. 
    Democratic impeachment managers had assailed that Wednesday as they answered questions from senators, and his own side had struggled to push back when asked what interest he had shown in corruption before Joe Biden ran for president.
    'I can't point to something in the record that shows President trump mentioning at an earlier time Joe and Hunter Biden,' Patrick Philbin, his deputy White House Counsel said Wednesday afternoon when asked by Democrats for concrete examples of his interest in investigating Hunter Biden before his father declared his candidacy.
    Bolton has never been named as being on the call and earlier this month Trump had dismissed him saying he would 'know nothing about what we're talking about.' 
    Discussing Bolton's knowledge of the call does however carry risk for Trump, as it could be used to limit any claim of executive privilege over their discussions. 
    The tweet was a few hours after the White House National Security Council was revealed to have told Bolton that his manuscript contained 'top secret' classified material and could not be published in its current form.  
    The letter from the White House National Security Council to Bolton's attorney, Charles Cooper throws the publication date of mid-March into doubt.
    'Under federal law and the nondisclosure agreements your client signed as a condition for gaining access to classified information, the manuscript may not be published or otherwise disclosed without the deletion of this classified information,' the letter said.
    But Cooper released a letter later Wednesday which was sent last week to the NSC and said 'we do not believe that any of the information could reasonably be considered classified,' and urged them to complete their review rapidly 'given that Ambassador Bolton could be called upon to testify as early as next week.'
     The directive from the NSC that the book 'may not be published' stands to have an immediate impact on the impeachment proceedings underway in the Senate.
    Republican senators are grappling with Democratic demands that the Senate subpoena Bolton to answer questions about Ukraine outlined in his manuscript.
    One GOP senator even floated the idea of obtaining the Bolton manuscript and putting it in a room where senators could view it – which could be done if a sign-off on classification was provided for viewing in a secure room.
    And at the trial Trump's attorneys were asked exactly when the White House counsel's office - which is led by Pat Cipollone, who is leading Trump's defense - know about Bolton's manuscript.
    Deputy White House Counsel Patrick Philbin said he did not know.
    'At some point,' he said. 'I don't know off the top of my head.'
    The answer is likely to be pursued further by Democrats. 
    Major blow: The White House National Security Council has written to John Bolton to tell him that some of his manuscript includes 'top secret' information and therefore it cannot be published in its current form
    Major blow: The White House National Security Council has written to John Bolton to tell him that some of his manuscript includes 'top secret' information and therefore it cannot be published in its current form. THis book title is apparently borrowed from the musical Hamilton
    Major blow: The White House National Security Council has written to John Bolton to tell him that some of his manuscript includes 'top secret' information and therefore it cannot be published in its current form
    He was in the room where it happens: John Bolton was a regular in the Oval Office until he left the White House saying he had resigned; Donald Trump claimed he was fired
    He was in the room where it happens: John Bolton was a regular in the Oval Office until he left the White House saying he had resigned; Donald Trump claimed he was fired
    White House bans Bolton book over 'top secret' information
    Progress: 0%
    0:00
    Previous
    Play
    Skip
    Mute
    Current Time0:00
    /
    Duration Time2:11
    Fullscreen
    Need Text
    Trump jokes about Senators and Impeachment trial
    Progress: 0%
    0:00
    Previous
    Play
    Skip
    Mute
    Current Time0:00
    /
    Duration Time0:53
    Fullscreen
    Need Text
    House impeachment manager Rep. Adam Schiff of California referenced the Bolton book on the Senate floor just minutes after news broke about the White House classification demand.
    'Don’t wait for the book. Don’t wait for March 17 when it is in black and white,' he urged senators, pleading with them to allow Bolton to speak. 
    Many authors who seek to write about matters that raise issues of classification go back and forth with government authorities seeking to publish material. But seeking advance approval is essential. 
    A Navy SEAL who wrote about the raid that killed Osama bin Laden was ordered to pay $6.8 million to the government for failing to get pre-publication approval.

No comments: