Monday, November 16, 2026

Sanctuary cities and the ghost of Southern segregationists

Sanctuary cities and the ghost of Southern segregationists


Autism article imageTheAmeliaMay, via Wikimedia Commons // CC BY-SA 4.0 Deed

An unappealing feature of today’s Democrats is their sanctuary-city or sanctuary-state policies.
 
Elected officials who refuse to allow local police and sheriffs to assist in ICE enforcement operations are effectively placing their own political preferences above federal law.
 
Such actions reveal their contempt for the federal government's constitutional authority. There is also something eerily familiar about this political posture. It is an echo from the past: the Southern segregationist governors, legislatures, and local officials who resisted federal school integration laws during the 1950s and 1960s à la Brown v. Board of Education.

Southern segregationists once invoked “local control” as a shield to evade federal civil rights law on school integration.
 
Today, sanctuary officials appeal to the same principle to protect illegal aliens from federal immigration enforcement. The causes differ, but the structure of the resistance is strikingly similar: local officials assert their authority against the supremacy of federal law.
 
That should give every American pause.

Defenders of sanctuary policies lean on Printz v. United States, in which the Supreme Court said Washington cannot “commandeer” local sheriffs to run background checks on gun buyers.
 
Perhaps so. But Printz is a thin reed on which to rest the defense of open borders. That case involved a narrow provision of federal law. To rely on a ruling about a narrow regulatory provision treats immigration enforcement as one more federal program that localities may decline to staff -- and that trivializes what is at stake. Knowing who lives in our communities, protecting public safety, and keeping traffickers and cartels from exploiting our borders are not regulatory housekeeping. They are among the first duties of a sovereign nation, and a legal technicality about who pays for the paperwork should not obscure that.

The issue is no longer theoretical.
 
In Texas, the fight is underway now. The recent November election results there show how quickly things can change. Texas law currently bars cities from limiting cooperation with federal immigration enforcement and mandates that sheriffs comply with all ICE detainer requests. But Democratic lawmakers have already filed bills to repeal those mandates, and the lieutenant governor-elect has called for undoing the state-level cooperation agreements that underpin these enforcement efforts.
 
Regardless of the intent, the effect would be to turn Texas jails and police departments into places where people here illegally are shielded from federal reach. That is a choice, and voters should understand what it means.
 
A nation cannot preserve equal citizenship if some cities help enforce federal law and others refuse. Federal immigration law must apply throughout the country, and enforcement must be consistent.

Abraham Lincoln defined our government as one “of the people, by the people, for the people.” That “people” is the American people, acting through laws they have chosen and officials who answer to them. It does not mean whoever happens to be inside our borders at the moment, and it does not mean local officials who decide which laws to obey.
 
A government that shelters those who broke the law to enter the country, at the expense of the citizens it protects, is no longer governing for the people it was created to serve.
 

No comments: