|
Socialism Is Not the Beginning
The peculiar economic theory that prosperity can be achieved by punishing the people who create it- is not the beginning, it is the end.
| |||||||||||||||
My Democrat/DSA friends (I can’t tell you apart these days), you bitch about how out of tilted our economy is toward the wealthy but you ever wonder whether taking money from productive people, redistributing it to people who produce less (or in some cases, nothing) and creating an ever-expanding class of citizens dependent upon government might actually be one of the reasons our economy becomes increasingly unbalanced?
Of course you don’t. That would require thinking about economics as something governed by tangible realities rather than a magical process in which money materializes whenever a politician discovers another group of people who deserve something for free.
We have developed a peculiar understanding of economics in this country, one in which wealth is treated as something that exists in a finite quantity, as if God deposited a few trillion dollars on Earth at the Creation and humanity has been fighting over who gets to keep it ever since. Under this theory, the existence of a billionaire necessarily explains the existence of a poor person. Somebody has too much because somebody else has too little, and the obvious solution is to appoint a committee of exceptionally enlightened people to decide how much everybody should have.
Naturally, the committee members will be compensated handsomely for their sacrifices.
A functioning free-market economy consists of different economic strata, with individuals moving among them according to their abilities, ambitions, circumstances, and sometimes plain old luck. At the upper levels, wealth is employed as capital, invested in enterprises that produce additional wealth. The middle classes produce and manage goods and services, accumulate assets, and pursue upward mobility. At the lower end are people with limited incomes, some requiring assistance, others beginning their economic lives, and still others encountering circumstances that make advancement difficult.
There is nothing inherently immoral about being poor, any more than there is something inherently immoral about being wealthy. Poverty is not a character defect, and wealth is not evidence of criminal activity. Unfortunately, we have constructed an entire political philosophy around convincing the lower economic classes that their circumstances are primarily the consequence of somebody else’s success. They have been told that wealth accumulated by others was somehow stolen from them, that their economic condition represents an injustice, and that government must correct it by confiscating and redistributing other people’s productivity.
Remarkably, this philosophy offers little explanation of how wealth is created. It is almost exclusively concerned with dividing wealth after somebody else creates it.
What, exactly, does socialism produce?
A factory produces automobiles. A farmer produces food. An engineer develops technologies that improve productivity. An entrepreneur combines capital, labor, and ideas to create enterprises producing things people voluntarily purchase because they consider them valuable.
Socialism, as an economic philosophy, produces none of these things by itself. It concerns itself with who owns the means of production, who controls the proceeds, and who decides how those proceeds are distributed. The productive activities remain necessary because even the most enthusiastic socialist has yet to discover how to manufacture an automobile out of social justice.
After the glorious revolution, the machinist will still operate his machine, the engineer will still design equipment, and the farmer will still grow food. The difference is that decisions concerning investment, compensation, production, and the disposition of whatever value they create will increasingly be controlled by political authorities rather than individuals operating in a competitive marketplace.
The worker hasn’t been liberated, quite the contrary. He has exchanged the possibility of economic independence for the promise that somebody in government will treat him fairly.
In other words, he has become a slave to the state.
In a free-market economy, the machinist might become a supervisor, plant manager, owner, or founder of a competing company. His prospects aren’t guaranteed, but he can acquire skills, accumulate capital, take risks, and move from one economic class into another.
Under centralized socialism, those opportunities become dependent upon political permission. Government determines what gets produced, where capital is invested, and what compensation is appropriate. The individual may work harder and produce more value, but the relationship between productivity and personal advancement is weakened by the priorities of those controlling the system.
This is where the economic death spiral begins.
When rewards for producing additional value are separated from those producing it, incentives to invest, innovate, and improve productivity deteriorate. Capital becomes something to confiscate rather than accumulate. Success becomes justification for additional taxation. Economic achievement becomes evidence that somebody received more than his fair share.
Meanwhile, the political class discovers that distributing wealth is considerably more popular than explaining where it comes from. Government expands redistribution programs, requiring additional revenue and greater demands upon the productive economy. Those demands discourage investment and expansion, creating more people who need assistance, which politicians use to justify expanding the programs that contributed to the problem.
Eventually, the people administering redistribution regard themselves as the essential component of the economy, while those producing the wealth become an inconvenient source of funding.
It is a wonderful arrangement, provided you’re doing the redistributing.
None of this means a prosperous society should abandon people who genuinely cannot provide for themselves. There is an enormous difference between maintaining a reasonable safety net and constructing a political economy in which permanent dependence becomes an acceptable, even desirable, condition.
Economic mobility, not economic equality, is the real measure of opportunity in a free society. The objective should be to preserve conditions under which individuals can improve their circumstances through productive activity. Socialism reverses that priority. It treats distributing existing wealth as more important than creating new wealth, eventually discovering that redistribution becomes considerably more difficult when the productive economy stops growing.
Socialist movements tend to arise in societies that have already accumulated substantial wealth. They require something to redistribute: factories already built, technologies already developed, infrastructure already financed, and capital somebody else accumulated. They arrive after the difficult work has been done, announce that prosperity is unfairly distributed, and promise to improve everything by changing who controls it.
The tragedy is that the machinery of prosperity can continue operating for a while after the incentives that created it have been dismantled. Accumulated capital can sustain an economy long enough for the architects of its destruction to congratulate themselves on their success, but every party comes to an end. By the time consequences become unavoidable, there is usually a convenient explanation involving insufficient socialism, capitalist sabotage, or ordinary people’s failure to appreciate the brilliance of their political leadership.
And then comes the double-down.
A free-market economy isn’t perfect because human beings aren’t perfect. Its great virtue is allowing individuals to create new value and improve their circumstances without requiring permission from a political committee. Socialism promises to correct human imperfections by concentrating economic power in the hands of other human beings, apparently assuming political authority somehow cures greed, envy, incompetence, and the desire to control others.
No one ever explains why an allegedly flawed individual can’t make the “right” decisions for themselves, but a committee of flawed Indi duals can. How’s that for some magical thinking?
Prosperity isn’t created by dividing wealth into progressively smaller pieces. It is created by allowing people to produce more of it. Socialism is what happens when a prosperous society forgets how its prosperity was created and decides distributing the fruits of productivity is more important than preserving the freedom to produce them.
That’s why we see the greatest promoters of socialism coming from the ranks of people who have never produced a damn thing.
Socialism is not the beginning.
It is the end.

No comments:
Post a Comment