Thursday, August 1, 2013
They are today's Brown Shirts/Black Shirts...the left's shock troops
Americans United for Change, run by a former Democratic National Committee communications head, plans to send activists to Republican town halls in swing states and even red states to target lawmakers like Sen. Ted Cruz (R-TX).
"This is a new approach. The theory in the past has been to be stealth about the effort to confront members at town halls--but sometimes it's been too stealth, and we haven’t generated enough activity," Brad Woodhouse, the president of the group, told the Huffington Post on Wednesday. "Since everyone knows that both sides are doing this, we're going to be public-facing about it."
According to Woodhouse, the progressive group "wants supporters to confront the elected officials, ask them tough questions and record the exchanges." The Huffington Post reports the group "plans to share noteworthy responses, and to collect and share information about what Republicans are doing and saying."
Labels:
anarchists,
Dissecting leftism,
Freedom,
progressivism
Economics
Larry Summers In Demand For His Economic Insights? That's a Laugh
By John Tamny
"Larry Summers believes that less fiscal austerity is the low-hanging fruit on stabilization and full-employment policy right now." - Brad DeLong, Wall Street Journal, July 31, 2013
The late William F. Buckley famously observed that he would take being ruled by the first 100 names in the Boston phone book over the faculties at Harvard and MIT. Full of book smart people with nosebleed IQs, the simple truth is that professors are the people who can't.
The above is particularly true when it comes to something as basic as economics. Economics is ultimately about growth, and growth is as simple as removing the tax, trade, regulatory, and monetary barriers to production. Put more simply, tax and regulate as a little as possible (taxes penalize work, regulations simply don't work), allow individuals to trade and invest their surplus with others irrespective of country, and provide them with a stable currency to measure and maximize the former. If you do that, you have stupendous growth. No numbers are needed.
All of which brings us to one of the most comical lines ever written on the front page of the Wall Street Journal. Though the newspaper is an increasingly lively source of information on all manner of subjects from business, to sports, to arts & entertainment, the front page has remained somewhat sober in its reportage. Sure enough, what was comical to this reader was presumably not meant to be funny despite it surely eliciting laughter from a high number of the Journal's sentient readers.
Specifically, last Saturday's edition, in an article about Harvard professor Lawrence Summers, noted that the Fed Chairman hopeful "has seen his views on the global economy, policy, and markets come into strong demand" since returning to the private sector (from the Obama administration) in 2011. When the laughing subsided after reading the latter I was reminded of the always wrong economists at Goldman Sachs in the ‘90s. Clients of Wall Street's foremost investment bank were known to keenly follow their research in order to profit from betting against it.
One might at first assume something similar is at work with Summers. That's the case because at least his modern economic analysis is rather devoid of insight.
Readers could doubtless point to so many examples supporting the above contention, but in the interest of time and space, it's best to touch on a few examples from the last several years. In January of 2008 Summers wrote in the Financial Timesthat renewed economic growth was as simple as "a $50bn-$75bn package implemented over two to three quarters [that] would provide about 1 per cent of gross domestic product in stimulus over the period of its implementation." More specifically, Summers was calling for Washington to distribute rebate checks to the citizenry in order to allegedly stimulate demand.
What's comical is that a simple analysis of the professor's musings reveals that rebates would logically restrain growth. That's the case because economic growth is about production of something desired by the marketplace, yet Summers was calling for no such thing. Instead, he was seeking a redistribution of wealth from one set of hands to another. There's no new production to speak of and surely no new demand, just a shift of demand by government force.
Importantly, the story gets worse. Empirical evidence is pretty clear that the rich account for the majority of federal tax revenues, so any rebates paid are going to logically result from society's most productive being fleeced so that its least productive receive checks. The incentives of Summers' plea for growth were more than backwards; raise the cost of work for the wealth creators while cushioning indolence among those who are least economically productive.
Keynesians reading this are doubtless seething, screaming that the poor and middle class are more likely to spend rebate checks, thus the purpose of forced wealth redistribution, but even the latter doesn't stand up to the most youthful of scrutiny. To put it plainly, no act of saving subtracts from demand. Banks don't accept deposits (liabilities) so that they can sit on the money; instead they offer interest on deposits so that they can take the funds deposited and turn them into loans (assets). Money saved never sits idle as much as it serves as capital for market-disciplined banks to lend out to entrepreneurs and those with immediate demands.
Thinking about the above, if we ignore how very much banks have become coddled supplicants of the political class, including Summers, they're far more likely to lend out monies saved in an economically stimulative way than governments are. Wasn't it Summers himself who once wisely uttered something along the lines of "government is a bad venture capitalist"?
Moving to Barack Obama's presidency, despite persistently weak economic growth amid massive government spending ‘stimulus,' Summers remained a cheerleader for same. This first revealed itself when he served Obama as director of the National Economic Council. Spending advocate Christina Romer confirmed this to Confidence Men author Ron Suskind. Romer recounted to Suskin that once Summers fully came on board with her failed notions about government spending ‘stimulus,' "[Larry and I] really started to have a decent working relationship."
Once back in the private sector, Summers' support for government spending became, if anything, even more strident. As he put it in the Financial Times last fall:
"Barack Obama has recognised the inadequacy of demand as the main barrier to growth and sought to bolster both public and private sector demand since becoming president. Recent work by the International Monetary Fund has confirmed the premise of his policies, namely that at a time when short-term interest rates are at zero, fiscal policies are especially potent as multipliers are larger than normal. "
Summers then added, falsely (Romney believed in the spending stimulus lie almost as much as Obama did), that:
"Mitt Romney, in contrast, supports immediate efforts to sharply reduce government spending even as economic slack remains..."
Ok, so this supposedly wise economist believes that economic growth is enhanced when money is taxed and borrowed away from Apple, Intel, and Google, and John Malone, Fred Smith and Jeff Bezos, so that government can dole it out. To be explicit, Summers believes that penalizing the most productive individuals and businesses all the while reducing the amount of investable capital (no entrepreneurs without capital, to quote Schumpeter) is the path to economic growth. Sorry, but that's what government ‘stimulus' is.
And it once again doesn't increase demand. It merely shifts it from the productive to the indolent; government serving as the venture capitalist backed by guns if the productive prove reluctant to hand over their hard-earned funds. Taking the absurdity of Summers' views even further, governments don't even create jobs.
The latter is surely difficult for romantic Keynesians to swallow, but it's really very simple. Governments don't have any resources. What they have to spend is a function of what they extract from the private sector first. Keynesians like Summers believe that government spending creates economic growth, but they get it exactly backwards. Government spending doesn't make us a prosperous and growing country, rather our federal government can spend nosebleed sums precisely because we're a prosperous and growing country. Big difference.
Looking at government spending, yes it ‘creates' jobs, but only insofar as the private sector hands it the revenues to do so. The private sector creates ALL jobs, yet the naïve lie that is Keynesianism is rooted in the belief that wealth springs from the very government whose wealth is solely a function of how productive is the private sector.
Notable about Summers is that while he has many detractors, some at least give him a pass for apparently not being as sympathetic as is Janet Yellen to the perversion of money that is "quantitative easing." Not so fast.
Summers has said that "there is less efficacy from quantitative easing than is supposed," but the latter is rooted in Keynesian worship of "aggregate demand." Summers believes that inflation results from too much demand, and since he thinks QE won't stimulate demand, that it's not inflationary. Where does one begin?
The main thing to point out is that demand is not inflationary despite what you read and hear. Demand is matched by production, or better yet we can only demand insofar as we produce first. If readers don't believe this, as in if they doubt the tautology that their supply is their demand, they need only cease working and see what they get for doing so. Unless the feds redistribute demand from others in the form of welfare checks, or charities do the same, or if they have productive friends who will hand to them the fruits of their labor for nothing, they will starve.
Inflation is not a function of too much demand simply because the latter is logically a function of commensurate supply. These things match. If demand were inflationary, then it would certainly be true that the ‘80s and ‘90s, when the U.S. economy boomed, were inflationary. In truth, the dollar was strong, a strong dollar feeds productivity gains, and a surge in demand (remember the ‘Decade of Greed') was naturally matched with a surge in supply.
Inflation is always and everywhere a function of currency devaluation. That's why QE hasn't boosted the economy, and it's also why the stock market (a forward looking indicator of growth) has rallied amid growing rumblings from the Fed that it will eventually wind down its QE program. Summers wasn't so much against QE as the deluded Keynesian in him labors under the absurd belief that demand doesn't result from supply.
All of which brings us back to the comical report from the Wall Street Journal about how the views of Summers have been very much in demand. Oh please. No reasonable investor would want to be ministered to by someone whose views are so impressively divorced from reality. Of course it's not due to Summers' ‘insights' that he's so popular on Wall Street.
Instead, it has to do with something far more basic, and touched on in Suskind's Confidence Men. In it, the author wrote of the $16 million paid to Rahm Emanuel during his brief stay at investment bank Wasserstein Perella; this despite Emanuel having no business experience. Of course, as a finance type explained to Suskind, Emanuel wasn't being paid for his business acumen. As he put it to the author, "Paying someone who will be a future government official a lot of money for doing very little? On Wall Street we call that an investment."
And there you have it. Larry Summers is surely very book smart, probably is great at crossword puzzles, and would likely be a wonderful Trivial Pursuit partner, but as evidenced by his views on what drives economic growth, his thoughts on the economy and markets are only useful insofar as a wise investor would bet against the forecasts of the Fed hopeful.
But that's not the point. Per Emanuel, Summers is an investment. Skillful at the government game, investors have long assumed he would eventually return to government; his name on the short list for Fed Chairman evidence that their investment may pay off. The latter is tragic to say the least, but it at least explains why someone so devoid of insight could have such a large bank account.
The late William F. Buckley famously observed that he would take being ruled by the first 100 names in the Boston phone book over the faculties at Harvard and MIT. Full of book smart people with nosebleed IQs, the simple truth is that professors are the people who can't.
All of which brings us to one of the most comical lines ever written on the front page of the Wall Street Journal. Though the newspaper is an increasingly lively source of information on all manner of subjects from business, to sports, to arts & entertainment, the front page has remained somewhat sober in its reportage. Sure enough, what was comical to this reader was presumably not meant to be funny despite it surely eliciting laughter from a high number of the Journal's sentient readers.
Specifically, last Saturday's edition, in an article about Harvard professor Lawrence Summers, noted that the Fed Chairman hopeful "has seen his views on the global economy, policy, and markets come into strong demand" since returning to the private sector (from the Obama administration) in 2011. When the laughing subsided after reading the latter I was reminded of the always wrong economists at Goldman Sachs in the ‘90s. Clients of Wall Street's foremost investment bank were known to keenly follow their research in order to profit from betting against it.
One might at first assume something similar is at work with Summers. That's the case because at least his modern economic analysis is rather devoid of insight.
Readers could doubtless point to so many examples supporting the above contention, but in the interest of time and space, it's best to touch on a few examples from the last several years. In January of 2008 Summers wrote in the Financial Timesthat renewed economic growth was as simple as "a $50bn-$75bn package implemented over two to three quarters [that] would provide about 1 per cent of gross domestic product in stimulus over the period of its implementation." More specifically, Summers was calling for Washington to distribute rebate checks to the citizenry in order to allegedly stimulate demand.
What's comical is that a simple analysis of the professor's musings reveals that rebates would logically restrain growth. That's the case because economic growth is about production of something desired by the marketplace, yet Summers was calling for no such thing. Instead, he was seeking a redistribution of wealth from one set of hands to another. There's no new production to speak of and surely no new demand, just a shift of demand by government force.
Importantly, the story gets worse. Empirical evidence is pretty clear that the rich account for the majority of federal tax revenues, so any rebates paid are going to logically result from society's most productive being fleeced so that its least productive receive checks. The incentives of Summers' plea for growth were more than backwards; raise the cost of work for the wealth creators while cushioning indolence among those who are least economically productive.
Keynesians reading this are doubtless seething, screaming that the poor and middle class are more likely to spend rebate checks, thus the purpose of forced wealth redistribution, but even the latter doesn't stand up to the most youthful of scrutiny. To put it plainly, no act of saving subtracts from demand. Banks don't accept deposits (liabilities) so that they can sit on the money; instead they offer interest on deposits so that they can take the funds deposited and turn them into loans (assets). Money saved never sits idle as much as it serves as capital for market-disciplined banks to lend out to entrepreneurs and those with immediate demands.
Thinking about the above, if we ignore how very much banks have become coddled supplicants of the political class, including Summers, they're far more likely to lend out monies saved in an economically stimulative way than governments are. Wasn't it Summers himself who once wisely uttered something along the lines of "government is a bad venture capitalist"?
Moving to Barack Obama's presidency, despite persistently weak economic growth amid massive government spending ‘stimulus,' Summers remained a cheerleader for same. This first revealed itself when he served Obama as director of the National Economic Council. Spending advocate Christina Romer confirmed this to Confidence Men author Ron Suskind. Romer recounted to Suskin that once Summers fully came on board with her failed notions about government spending ‘stimulus,' "[Larry and I] really started to have a decent working relationship."
Once back in the private sector, Summers' support for government spending became, if anything, even more strident. As he put it in the Financial Times last fall:
"Barack Obama has recognised the inadequacy of demand as the main barrier to growth and sought to bolster both public and private sector demand since becoming president. Recent work by the International Monetary Fund has confirmed the premise of his policies, namely that at a time when short-term interest rates are at zero, fiscal policies are especially potent as multipliers are larger than normal. "
Summers then added, falsely (Romney believed in the spending stimulus lie almost as much as Obama did), that:
"Mitt Romney, in contrast, supports immediate efforts to sharply reduce government spending even as economic slack remains..."
Ok, so this supposedly wise economist believes that economic growth is enhanced when money is taxed and borrowed away from Apple, Intel, and Google, and John Malone, Fred Smith and Jeff Bezos, so that government can dole it out. To be explicit, Summers believes that penalizing the most productive individuals and businesses all the while reducing the amount of investable capital (no entrepreneurs without capital, to quote Schumpeter) is the path to economic growth. Sorry, but that's what government ‘stimulus' is.
And it once again doesn't increase demand. It merely shifts it from the productive to the indolent; government serving as the venture capitalist backed by guns if the productive prove reluctant to hand over their hard-earned funds. Taking the absurdity of Summers' views even further, governments don't even create jobs.
The latter is surely difficult for romantic Keynesians to swallow, but it's really very simple. Governments don't have any resources. What they have to spend is a function of what they extract from the private sector first. Keynesians like Summers believe that government spending creates economic growth, but they get it exactly backwards. Government spending doesn't make us a prosperous and growing country, rather our federal government can spend nosebleed sums precisely because we're a prosperous and growing country. Big difference.
Looking at government spending, yes it ‘creates' jobs, but only insofar as the private sector hands it the revenues to do so. The private sector creates ALL jobs, yet the naïve lie that is Keynesianism is rooted in the belief that wealth springs from the very government whose wealth is solely a function of how productive is the private sector.
Notable about Summers is that while he has many detractors, some at least give him a pass for apparently not being as sympathetic as is Janet Yellen to the perversion of money that is "quantitative easing." Not so fast.
Summers has said that "there is less efficacy from quantitative easing than is supposed," but the latter is rooted in Keynesian worship of "aggregate demand." Summers believes that inflation results from too much demand, and since he thinks QE won't stimulate demand, that it's not inflationary. Where does one begin?
The main thing to point out is that demand is not inflationary despite what you read and hear. Demand is matched by production, or better yet we can only demand insofar as we produce first. If readers don't believe this, as in if they doubt the tautology that their supply is their demand, they need only cease working and see what they get for doing so. Unless the feds redistribute demand from others in the form of welfare checks, or charities do the same, or if they have productive friends who will hand to them the fruits of their labor for nothing, they will starve.
Inflation is not a function of too much demand simply because the latter is logically a function of commensurate supply. These things match. If demand were inflationary, then it would certainly be true that the ‘80s and ‘90s, when the U.S. economy boomed, were inflationary. In truth, the dollar was strong, a strong dollar feeds productivity gains, and a surge in demand (remember the ‘Decade of Greed') was naturally matched with a surge in supply.
Inflation is always and everywhere a function of currency devaluation. That's why QE hasn't boosted the economy, and it's also why the stock market (a forward looking indicator of growth) has rallied amid growing rumblings from the Fed that it will eventually wind down its QE program. Summers wasn't so much against QE as the deluded Keynesian in him labors under the absurd belief that demand doesn't result from supply.
All of which brings us back to the comical report from the Wall Street Journal about how the views of Summers have been very much in demand. Oh please. No reasonable investor would want to be ministered to by someone whose views are so impressively divorced from reality. Of course it's not due to Summers' ‘insights' that he's so popular on Wall Street.
Instead, it has to do with something far more basic, and touched on in Suskind's Confidence Men. In it, the author wrote of the $16 million paid to Rahm Emanuel during his brief stay at investment bank Wasserstein Perella; this despite Emanuel having no business experience. Of course, as a finance type explained to Suskind, Emanuel wasn't being paid for his business acumen. As he put it to the author, "Paying someone who will be a future government official a lot of money for doing very little? On Wall Street we call that an investment."
And there you have it. Larry Summers is surely very book smart, probably is great at crossword puzzles, and would likely be a wonderful Trivial Pursuit partner, but as evidenced by his views on what drives economic growth, his thoughts on the economy and markets are only useful insofar as a wise investor would bet against the forecasts of the Fed hopeful.
But that's not the point. Per Emanuel, Summers is an investment. Skillful at the government game, investors have long assumed he would eventually return to government; his name on the short list for Fed Chairman evidence that their investment may pay off. The latter is tragic to say the least, but it at least explains why someone so devoid of insight could have such a large bank account.
Labels:
economics,
economists
How the administration panders to unions
Feds give laid-off Boeing workers a big helping hand
Local Boeing workers who’ve lost their jobs will receive substantial additional federal unemployment benefits after two unions at the company sought aid under a program for employees laid off due to outsourcing and foreign trade.
Seattle Times aerospace reporter
Federal help for Boeing Commercial Airplanes’ laid-off workers
Extended unemployment pay for up to 2½ years
A 72.5 percent tax credit on health-care insurance premiums
90 percent of travel expenses to a job interview covered up to $1,250
90 percent of relocation expenses for a new job, plus a relocation lump sum up to $1,250
Supplemental pay for workers older than 50 re-employed in a lower-paid job, up to $10,000 over two years
Up to $25,000 training grant toward cost of a college degree
Source: state Employment Security Department
MOST POPULAR COMMENTS
HIDE / SHOW COMMENTS
Read all 60 comments
Post a comment
Thanks to a federal program lined up by their unions, local workers laid off during the current dip in employment at Boeing Commercial Airplanes will enjoy a financial cushion that’s much, much plumper than what the average unemployed state resident gets.
“Compared to what Joe Worker gets when they get laid off, our members have a pretty extensive safety net,” said Connie Kelliher, spokeswoman for the International Association of Machinists (IAM).
The U.S. Department of Labor has approved Boeing workers — union or nonunion, production workers or engineers — laid off between April 2012 and June 2015 for a package of benefits that includes drawing unemployment pay for up to 2½ years, rather than the regular six months.
The Labor Department ruling also means that if laid-off Boeing workers need to travel, say to California, for a job interview, the government will reimburse 90 percent of the costs.
If they relocate for a new job, the government will pay 90 percent of their moving expenses and provide an additional lump-sum relocation allowance of up to $1,250.
While unemployed, they’ll also get a tax credit for nearly three-quarters of their health-care premiums. And they’re eligible for a grant of up to $25,000 toward the cost of a degree.
And for those workers over 50, if they have to take a lower-paid job after leaving Boeing, the government will provide up to $10,000 over two years in supplementary pay to make up some of the difference.
All these benefits flow because the Labor Department recently granted the IAM’s petition for federal aid under the Trade Adjustment Assistance (TAA) program, which is designed to assist U.S. workers who have lost their jobs as a result of overseas trade or outsourcing.
And after a parallel petition from the white-collar union, the Society of Professional Engineering Employees in Aerospace (SPEEA), the government broadened the approval to include all Boeing Commercial Airplanes workers, even nonunion employees.
The Department of Labor explained the decision by saying the company’s job losses here can be attributed to outsourcing because Boeing has acquired aircraft parts from foreign countries, “which contributed importantly to worker group separations.”
In addition to producing overseas airplane parts such as the wings of the 787, Boeing has outsourced engineering work to its 787 partners overseas and also employs about 1,000 engineers at its Moscow design center.
A similar petition by the IAM on behalf of its members at Boeing Wichita was turned down by the Labor Department on the grounds that Boeing is transferring the military work formerly done in Wichita to Washington state, not overseas.
After increasing its Washington workforce by about 14,000 over three years, Boeing in the first half of 2013 laid off more than 1,100 employees.
Boeing has said that by year end it will have laid off a total of about 800 Machinists and some 700 SPEEA-represented engineering and technical staff.
For them, the TAA approval is timely because recession-generated federal emergency funding that extends benefits beyond six months for all the unemployed is winding down, with the final such payments in December.
The substantial TAA benefits for the Boeing workforce are on top of extras that the unions had already negotiated with the company.
Boeing agreed to pay an extra $700 in severance pay to laid-off IAM members who had been with the company less than a year.
And per the contract, any IAM member who has been with the company more than a year gets Boeing severance pay equal to a week of pay for every year of service, up to 26 weeks, plus full medical coverage for themselves and their dependents for up to six months.
The SPEEA contract provides the same severance-pay provision and up to three months of medical coverage.
Kelliher said the union pushes for extra protection for its members, both in the contract and through federal TAA support, “because we recognize that this industry is cyclical and you need that safety net for them.”
Howard Rosen, executive director of the Trade Adjustment Assistance Coalition, which advocates for the TAA program, said Congress has reauthorized the assistance as a quid pro quo for the steady embrace of free-trade rules by a succession of presidents that have encouraged imports and outsourcing.
“This has been the trade-off for giving the president the authority to conduct trade negotiations,” said Rosen, who helped draft 2002 reforms to the TAA legislation. “In exchange for that, we should help those people who are going to be hurt.”
According to the latest annual report for the TAA program, the Labor Department approved 1,134 petitions covering an estimated 81,510 workers for the fiscal year ended September 2012.
That year, the program paid out a total $855 million in income support and $575 million more for training, employment and case-management services, job-search allowances, relocation allowances and program administration.
That’s total funding of $1.4 billion, of which Washington state got almost $41 million.
Rosen concedes that the TAA program, born out of the politics of trade liberalization, may seem unfair to workers laid off for reasons unconnected with trade.
“I would love to have a program ... that is given to all workers regardless of the cause of their dislocation,” he said. “But politically, we are not there.”
Indeed, the pressure today is to cut, not broaden, unemployment assistance. Rosen said that when TAA funding expires at the end of this year, reauthorization will be a big political challenge.
But Boeing workers are in under the wire. If the TAA is not renewed, benefits will continue for those groups already in the system, including any Boeing Commercial Airplanes employees laid off during the next two years.
Alan Tonelson, a research fellow with the U.S. Business and Industry Council, said the main complaint about the program from critics of U.S. corporate offshoring like himself is that though well-organized unions make use of the program, individuals who are not in unions often don’t realize they are eligible.
“Many workers whose jobs have been lost to foreign competition or whose jobs have been offshored, don’t know about TAA and therefore do not apply,” said Tonelson.
The IAM has held four orientation sessions in Everett and Tukwila, where eligible employees could register for benefits, and it will have four more sessions in August.
The TAA funds are not the only federal money released by Boeing’s announced layoffs.
The Workforce Development Council of Snohomish County (WDCSC), a private not-for-profit that works with the state Employment Security department, anticipates a federal grant of $2 million to provide support services specifically for laid-off Boeing workers throughout the Puget Sound area.
Obamaphones and one reason Carlos Slim is one of the richest men in the world
Not on welfare or below the poverty line? Never mind — here’s your free phone.
Confession: You’re paying my phone bill.
In the past month, I have received three shiny new cell phones, courtesy of American taxpayers, that should never have fallen into my hands.
The Federal Communications Commission oversees the so-called Lifeline program, created in 1984 to make sure impoverished Americans had telephone service available to call their moms, bosses, and 911. In 2008, the FCC expanded the program to offer subsidized cell-phone service, and since then, the expenses of running the program have soared. In 2012, the program’s costs had risen to $2.189 billion, up from $822 million before wireless carriers were included. As of June, there were 13.8 million active Lifeline subscriptions.
To be eligible for Lifeline, the applicant is supposed to be receiving some significant government benefit — food stamps, Medicaid, Supplemental Security Income, public housing assistance, etc. But because welfare eligibility has expanded under the Obama administration, more people than ever before are qualified to receive “free” cell-phone service — part of the reason why Lifeline mobiles have become commonly known as Obamaphones. Alternatively, applicants can qualify if their household income is less than 136 percent of the federal poverty line.
But as with any federal program with too much funding, too little oversight, and perverse financial incentives, Lifeline has become infamous for rampant fraud and abuse. There have been news reports about recipients flaunting dozens of subsidized phones. And in February, the Wall Street Journal reported on an FCC audit of the top five Lifeline providers, which found that “41% of their more than six million subscribers either couldn’t demonstrate their eligibility or didn’t respond to requests for certification.”
The FCC supposedly buckled down on eligibility standards last year and established other safeguards aimed at reducing fraud. I was curious about how tough it was to get one of these phones, so last month, I hit the streets of New York. And out of respect for the law and my journalistic integrity, I did not lie to obtain a phone.
Now is the point, I suppose, where I should explain that I really, really shouldn’t have received a single phone. Despite what you hear, not all 20-something writers in the Big City are starving. Given my earnings, even if I were supporting a family of eight, my income would still rule me out. Nor do I receive any type of government benefit. By the Lifeline program’s standards, I am unambiguously ineligible.My first task was figuring out where to register. The rule of thumb is that wherever you can sign up for food stamps, you can apply for an Obamaphone.
Representatives from SafeLink and Assurance, two of the leading New York Lifeline vendors, stand outside the food-stamp offices, paired like Mormon missionaries, young and polite and earnest. They carry electronic tablets and ask all passersby whether they’ve received their free phone “yet” — as if it were an inevitability.
They approached me for the first time outside the food-stamp office at Tenth Avenue and 216th Street, on the northern tip of Manhattan. The SafeLink vendor, a man probably in his mid 20s, asked me whether I was enrolled in any benefit programs.
“No,” I said, “but I’d certainly like to be. I’m hoping to be.” And indeed, while doing research for another story, I had gone through the motions of applying for New York City welfare, which I also don’t qualify for. I showed him my Human Resources Administration paperwork packet and the case number assigned to me. I reiterated that though I had once applied, I had never been approved for any sort of benefit.
He brought out his electronic tablet immediately to sign me up for phone service. He asked if I had an insurance card, so I pulled out my trusty Blue Cross Blue Shield. He looked at it for a second, puzzled, then asked if I had Medicaid. No, I told him, just private insurance through my work plan.
“Private insurance? What’s that?” he asked, maybe not facetiously. My BCBS card was nevertheless photographed, as well as the first page of my Human Resources Administration paperwork. He asked for my name and my home address, and that was about it. The whole process took less than five minutes, and I had to provide no documentation verifying my income level or (nonexistent) welfare status.
The SafeLink vendor then referred me to his opposite number, a rep from Assurance. She too took down my information, registering me for another Obamaphone.
Traveling to several of the welfare offices in the city, I learned this was common practice. Obamaphone reps come in twos, and both will sign you up if they can.
That’s a very questionable practice, given the Lifeline program’s rules: Each eligible household may receive only one Lifeline subsidy, and obtaining multiple subsidized phones from multiple Lifeline carriers is “a flat-out violation of our rules,” says Michelle Schaefer, an attorney-adviser from the FCC’s Telecommunications Access Policy Division, Wireline Competition Bureau.
Schaefer also tells me that “consumers are, on their applications, required to certify under penalty of perjury that they will only be receiving one Lifeline discount.”
But when I went around New York signing up for multiple phones, I never even saw the applications; SafeLink and Assurance vendors filled out the necessary forms on their tablets on my behalf, clicking through so quickly that it must have been nearly muscle memory. And nobody mentioned perjury.
Granted, the first question the wireless reps asked was usually whether I was already enrolled in the Lifeline program. I told the truth: I had signed up recently, but the phone hadn’t arrived in the mail yet. Almost always, that got me re-entered into the system without hesitation.
When I did receive my SafeLink phone a few days later, I started informing vendors that I did have one Lifeline phone. They assured me that the Lifeline program permitted me to have one phone from eachparticipating wireless provider — which simply isn’t true.
Maybe there’s a disconnect between the corporate offices of wireless providers and their men on the street; a letter I later received from Assurance mentioned that “a household is not permitted to receive Lifeline benefits from multiple providers. Violation of the one-per-household rule constitutes a violation of federal rules and will result in de-enrollment from the Lifeline program and potentially prosecution by the United States government.”
But the wireless providers aren’t doing much due diligence, if my experience is indicative.
At the Union Square location, a SafeLink rep noted that I was already approved for a phone and declined to re-enter my information — but the rep from Assurance, standing only a few feet away, readily signed me up.
At the welfare office on Schermerhorn Street in Brooklyn, a vendor hesitated when I told her that I’d already applied but the phone had not yet been delivered. “Surely your system will catch if I’m actually enrolled,” I told her. She shrugged and signed me up once more.
At the DeKalb Avenue office in Brooklyn, when I told the rep I wasn’t receiving welfare, I was signed up for a phone but cautioned that I might well be denied upon secondary review.
And at one Lifeline location in East Harlem, I walked up to the wireless representative talking very loudly on my own smartphone. I hung up only to answer her questions. Now, keep in mind that the program is supposed to provide cell-phone service to people too poor to afford any phone whatsoever — but my application for a subsidized mobile was happily submitted, even as I dinked around very obviously on my existing smartphone.
So here’s the final count: I was able to apply on the street for one SafeLink phone and seven Assurance phones. I received one SafeLink phone and two Assurance phones, no questions asked. For several other applications, Assurance sent me requests for more financial information.
Finally, I received one other letter, full of grammatical errors, informing me that “there is already an Assurance Wireless account established at this address” and requesting further information about my application. I find it curious that Assurance caught a duplicate only once, considering that I’ve got seven entries in their system, and that they have on file my name, address, HRA case number, and, in some instances, photos of my insurance card and driver’s license. SafeLink was slightly better about catching duplications on the street, but it still gave me a phone when it shouldn’t have.
Since receiving my undeserved phones, I’ve repeatedly tried to reach both SafeLink and Assurance press reps for comment, all to no avail. Their corporate offices have sent me the numbers of their customer-service centers, which are easily accessible and happy to offer plan upgrades to Lifeline clients.
Representative Tim Griffin (R., Ark.) has long opposed the Lifeline wireless subsidies, making it a pet cause. He reiterated the basic point I had learned from this experience: The problems began when the federal government got in the business of providing free cell phones, and the FCC’s recent reforms aren’t sufficient.
“I saw all the horror stories of people getting 10, 20, 30, 40 phones,” Griffin says, “the [wireless] companies not paying a lot of attention and in some cases no attention to who was getting them and whether they were getting duplicates.”
And if you’ve been wondering why the companies are so eager to hand out free phones, the incentive is built into the program. As Griffin explains, “Of course, the way the program was set up, [wireless companies] were getting money for every one they could give out, so they gave out as many as they could.”
And still do.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)