'2008 Called...': Philly Plans City-Subsidized Mortgages With 3% Down And No Mortgage Insurance
Philadelphia is preparing to launch a city-subsidized mortgage that lets first-time buyers put down as little as 3% and skip private mortgage insurance, with public money covering part of the interest.
Called One Philly Mortgage, the program is part of Mayor Cherelle Parker's H.O.M.E. housing initiative. The city's flyer sets aside $25 million for "Low-Interest Mortgage Loans and down payments of no more than 3%," with "No Private Mortgage Insurance required." Parker described it to a special session of City Council in March 2025 as 30-year fixed-rate loans at "competitive interest rates."
The Philadelphia Housing Development Corporation's program page says the loans will go through local lenders, with public funds paying a portion of the interest. The city has not published the interest rate, a credit-score minimum or the application rules, which it says are still being finalized. Realtor Noelle Carter, who reviewed the preliminary plans, puts the floor at a 620 credit score. Buyers earning up to 120% of the area median income would qualify, and the Philadelphia Inquirer reports the administration intends to launch later this year.
Mortgage insurance is not a small item. Freddie Mac puts the cost at $30 to $70 a month for every $100,000 borrowed, which on a $350,000 loan comes to $105 to $245 a month, or $1,260 to $2,940 a year. The insurance exists to cover the lender when a borrower with little equity defaults. Under One Philly Mortgage the buyer does not pay it, and nothing the city has published says who carries that risk instead.
The cushion is thin. The median listing price in the Philadelphia metro area is about $375,000, so a 3% down payment is $11,250 and the loan is $363,750. A 3% drop in the home's price would erase the buyer's entire equity before a single selling cost.
The private market already offers low-down-payment loans, with the insurance attached. Fannie Mae backs 97% loan-to-value mortgages for first-time buyers, and Freddie Mac's Home Possible and HomeOne programs go to 3% down as well. What the city adds is the missing insurance bill and a subsidized rate.
The setup recalls an argument ZeroHedge has run before.
Kevin Villani, in a piece published here from the Mises Institute, contended that housing mandates forced Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac to "continuously lower their credit scoring thresholds" and accept "zero-down-payment structures" before 2008.
Philadelphia's plan is not zero down, and a fixed rate is not a teaser rate, but a government-subsidized lender is again taking on buyers with almost no stake in the house.
It also arrives as the housing market is seizing up: pending home sales collapsed to record lows in September.
The money is also slow to leave the building. The Inquirer, reporting on a City Controller review, found that as of Sept. 30 the city had spent $38 million of the $278 million budgeted for the first phase of H.O.M.E., which Controller Christy Brady called "only a little over 13%." Only four of the 29 approved programs had spent anything, all of them existing ones, so One Philly Mortgage's $25 million sits among the unspent. Angela Brooks, the city's chief housing and urban development officer, told the paper the city expects "to spend at a faster pace for the rest of the fiscal year."
The H.O.M.E. initiative is funded mainly by $800 million in city bonds, with the first $400 million issued this year. The city has put $25 million behind the mortgage program and has not said how many loans that supports or who covers the losses if they fail.
Posts
No comments:
Post a Comment